Polish Mystery Box

Polish Mystery Box

$40
$74  Value  Value  $40
Skip to product information
Save
Polish Mystery Box

4.7

1,000,000+ Happy Customers

1,000,000+ Happy customers

$40
$74  Value  Value  $40 Save $34

Surprise! Over $74 of O&J packed into one limited-edition mystery box. Packed with bestselling polishes and essentials including-lasting + quick dry polishes, limited edition colors, low-stock styles, and maybe even a throwback shade originally released over 5 years ago. Once they're gone, they're gone forever.

So… what will you find? $40 ($74 Value)

You might also love

BEAUTIFUL NAILS FOR EVERYONE

EVERYBODY IS GOING DIY

SKIP THE SALON

Overall rating: 4.65 / 5 from 20 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Summary topics

Review topics: ["color","box","polish","lasting","order","variety","effect","top coat","choice","deal"].

Review highlights

Reviews

Really pretty colors, but I

"Really pretty colors, but I was disappointed since 5 out 6 colors were pretty nude, I received only 1 solid color. I understand it was a mystery box so I guess I cant complain. Dont get me wrong, the nudes are truly gorgeous, but I was hoping for some 'color' too."

— Sumathi P. (3/5)

I received 7 polishes and

"I received 7 polishes and some nail files. 6 long lasting and one quick dry. I got a top coat and a glitter coat. Mostly neutrals and nothing extremely rare but all in all money well spent"

— Cheryl D. (5/5)

Really fun mystery bundle!

"Really fun variety in colors and finishes (long lasting vs quick dry). I got a nude, pink, gold effect top coat, light blue, green, orange, iridescent and top coat. I was so happy with the variety and wearability. Great deal and very fun to be surprised."

— Gabrielle C. (5/5)

Good Variety

"I got a pretty decent selection of colors, including a quick dry polish. I also got 2 top coats (long lasting and golden effect). One of the bottles had a scuff on the cap, but not a major issue for me."

— Isabelle B. (4/5)

Great mystery box!

"I was pleasantly surprised with the solid color choices. I found some in the style I like, a new color to try, and only one that doesn't suit me (and that one went to a friend!). Would buy again and recommend!"

— Heather H. (5/5)

Mystery Polish box

"It was fun getting the box & the colors were very pretty with a few duplicates I already had. I use mostly Quick dry & most were Long lasting but I shared with my sister & niece to try out the products because I like them so much."

— Marisa T. (4/5)

Not a great mix of colors

"I really like the olive and June formula for the long lasting polish. The colors I received were mostly all “see through” like you can see your nail underneath 2 coats of paint. Next time I’ll probably just pick my own colors instead of the mystery pack!"

— Melissa B. (2/5)

I love the variety of

"I love the variety of surprise polishes in the mystery box! My daughter and I shared them! I would definitely get a mystery box, again!"

— Lisa P. (5/5)

What a great surprise with

"What a great surprise with a mixture of quick dry, long lasting, and special effects! Loved receiving some pops of colors along with shimmery neutrals! Overall extremely satisfied!"

— Laurie P. (5/5)

Super excited!!!

"I loved all of the colors that I received! I got a long last top coat and a golden effects top coat which I never even thought of trying, but can't wait to! For my polishes, I received 5 of them, and they are alll so pretty and bright colors!!!!"

— Kenzie (5/5)

Q&A

Are all polish mystery boxes the same? Or if I order two will I get different items?
Great question! Our polish mystery boxes are all the same, so if you order two, you’ll receive identical items in each box.
How many polishes do you get in the mystery boxes
Great question! Our mystery boxes include 6–7 polishes. Each one is a fun surprise mix of shades!